The Truth About Income Taxes (Worse Than You Think)

  • Kiss your second middle-class tax cut goodbye
  • Why the income tax burden falls heaviest on the middle class
  • Rally time? Here comes the sweet spot of the four-year election cycle
  • Inflation numbers run hot, gold tumbles (what!?)
  • Crude tumbles into bear market… Gillette’s strategic retreat in the razor blade wars… what not to say to a poll worker… and more!

So much for the oh-so-ballyhooed “second tax cut.”

About three weeks ago, the president promised a 10% tax cut targeting the middle class effective next year — perhaps because much of the benefit from the tax cut this year was offset by rising gasoline prices.

At the time, House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Kevin Brady (R-Texas) appeared to rule out any tax cut action during the “lame duck” session of Congress in November and December. Wait till next year, in other words.

And with Democrats taking over the House come January… the whole thing’s now a moot point. Enjoy the middle-class tax cut you’ve got now… because that’s all you’re getting.

What’s more, if you’re middle class, you’re carrying a disproportionate share of the tax burden.

The reality is that the rich are not taxed, says Rich Dad Poor Dad author Robert Kiyosaki. “It’s the middle class who pays for the poor.”

At an early age, Robert says he learned from his “rich dad” mentor that — aside from the Civil War — income taxes were unheard of in the United States until the 16th Amendment was ratified in 1913.

“It took approximately 50 years for the U.S. to sell the idea of a regular income tax,” says Robert. And the key selling point was that only the rich would pay. “The idea of taxes was made popular by telling the poor and the middle class that taxes were created to punish the rich.”

Under the Revenue Act of 1913, a 1% tax was levied on net personal incomes above $3,000 — or about $76,000 in today’s dollars. That was it — apart from a graduated surtax on incomes starting about $507,000 in today’s dollars.

Although the income tax was intended to punish the rich, it wound up punishing the poor and middle class,Robert goes on.

“The problem was that the government’s appetite for money was so great that taxes soon needed to be levied on the middle class, and from there it kept trickling down.

“But the rich saw an opportunity because they don’t play by the same set of rules. The rich knew about corporations.

“It is the knowledge of the legal corporate structure that really gives the rich a vast advantage.

“Bottom line: No matter what the ‘take from the rich’ crowd came up with, the rich always found a way to outsmart them.”

For proof of Robert’s assertion, we return to one of the most important book passages we’ve shared over the years in The 5. It’s from the 2009 book Endless Money, by the Baltimore-based money manager Bill Baker.

Tycoons such as Soros and Buffett can call for higher taxation of income,Baker wrote — and that emphasis on the word incomemakes all the difference. 

“This is a very cynical and downright mendacious strategy, for they know full well this burden would fall primarily upon members of the upper middle class, who have not yet achieved the threshold that would permit them to shift income to tax-minimizing structures…

“Once a certain threshold of wealth is achieved, taxpayers have some latitude in structuring when and where income originates.”

Thus, Google founders Larry Page and Sergey Brin “pay themselves just $1 in W-2 income,” Baker wrote, “but each year, they may accrue millions or even billions in unrealized capital gain.”

How did we reach this sorry state of affairs? For Robert, once again it comes back to education.

The pointy-headed intellectuals who write tax legislation — people like his “poor dad,” who was a government official — will always be outfoxed by rich people who understand the power of money — knowledge not taught in schools.

“The problem,” says Robert, “is that the people who lose are the uneducated: the ones who get up every day and diligently go to work and pay taxes. If they only understood the way the rich play the game, they could play it too. Then they would be on their way to their own financial security.

This is why I cringe every time I hear a parent advise their children to go to school so they can find a safe, secure job, Robert laments. “An employee with a safe, secure job without financial aptitude has no escape.

“Average Americans today work four–five months for the government just to cover their taxes. In my opinion, that is simply too long. The harder you work, the more you pay the government.

“Every time people try to punish the rich, the rich don’t simply comply. They react. They have the money, power and intent to change things. They don’t just sit there and voluntarily pay more taxes.”

Sure, you could get mad. But it’s better to get rich — or at least richer than you are now.

That’s the whole reason Robert is organizing the Weekly Cash Flow Summit next Wednesday at 1:00 p.m. EST. It will be his debut event as a member of the Agora Financial family.

At that time, he’ll introduce you to a new way to pull down a weekly stream of cash — payments of $840… $4,540… even as much as $10,600. Again, that’s every week — and regardless of market conditions. (You might incur some tax liability, but with gains like those you’ll still be well ahead of the game!)

Attendance is free, but space is limited. Reserve your spot now at this link and you’re in.

The major U.S. stock indexes are in the red this morning, but still on track for a big weekly gain by day’s end.

At last check, the Dow is holding up best, with a loss of less than 1% at 25,962. The Nasdaq is getting hit hardest, down 1.75% at 7,398.

⇒ A noteworthy exception to the selling — the consumer products giant Procter & Gamble, up a bit after announcing it would cut some management fat, a move our Zach Scheidt anticipated in this space a year ago.

“After a gigantic bounce of nearly 9% off the lows, the stock market has used up a lot of energy and may need to take a breather,” says income contributor Mike Burnick. “With the market now short-term overbought, I would not be surprised to see stocks take a ‘pause for the cause’ and do some backing and filling in the weeks ahead.”

But beyond the next few weeks, Mike says it’s looking great — simply based on where we are in the four-year presidential election cycle.

“The S&P 500 has been higher six months after each of the last 18 midterm elections,” he tells us, “gaining an average of 12%.”

Courtesy of the respected Ned Davis Research, here’s a chart of the market’s quarterly average performance across every four-year cycle going back to the end of World War II.

“As you can see,” says Mike, “the period starting now through mid-2019 has historically led to supercharged upside for stocks.”


Mike’s bottom line: “While it’s possible the market could pull back to test the recent lows, history tells us that these powerful seasonal trends are very bullish right now.”

Meanwhile, the commodity complex is getting clobbered. 

West Texas Intermediate crude just cracked below the $60 level — a 22% drop in barely a month. And gold is down more than 15 bucks to $1,207. That’s a $25 drop for the week.

Ironically, gold’s tumble this morning began at the very moment we got indications inflation is running hotter than previously thought.

The Bureau of Labor Statistics said wholesale prices jumped 0.6% in October — the biggest monthly jump in six years. Among dozens of economists polled by Econoday, the average guess was a 0.2% increase.

Usually, hotter inflation pushes the dollar price of gold higher. But a number like today’s only increases expectations that the Federal Reserve will continue to “tighten” monetary policy, and that’s a drag on gold.

Certainly the Fed signaled more tightening yesterday in its every-six-weeks policy statement. This morning, traders in fed funds futures are pricing in a 76% probability of another increase in the fed funds rate six weeks hence.

All that said, the question is whether producers can pass along rising wholesale prices to you and me. We’ll get a handle on that with the consumer price index next week.

Back to Procter & Gamble: It’s not just the management structure that’s getting streamlined. So is one of the company’s signature products.


Starting with the three-blade Mach3 in 1998, Gillette has kept upping the blade ante — culminating in the Fusion of 2009, featuring five blades plus a sixth on the back for sideburns and mustaches. For a while, competitors were running parody commercials on TV.

This week during Gillette’s Global Innovation Summit in New York — yes, there is such a thing and that’s what they call it — the company rolled out the two-blade SkinGuard Sensitive.

But they’re not just any blades, no sirree — per the company, they’re “two optimally placed low cutting force (LCF) blades” featuring “Gillette’s sharpest edges with [its] most advanced coatings.”

Gizmodo writer Adam Clark Estes is unimpressed: “It did not feel too much different than the two-blade Gillette razor my gym gives away for free. If anything, I’d say that it irritated my skin a little bit more than the Fusion blades I use at home.”

A four-pack of the SkinGuard cartridges will set you back $18, compared with $10 for a four-pack of the Mach3. “That means the two-blade Gillette razor costs almost twice what the three-blade one costs. Put differently, you can buy the Mach3 for almost half the price of the SkinGuard and get 50% more blades.”

Apparently “low cutting force” comes at a high premium!

On the election-week subject of “I voted” stickers, a reader writes…

“During the last midterm election in 2014 I decided to try early voting. When I finished one of the election judges handed me my sticker. Patriotic, with its red, white and blue colors it said simply ‘I voted early!’

“I looked at it, turned to the poll worker who had given it to me and said, ‘Thank you. I’ll be back tomorrow to get the one that says, “I voted often!”’

“Needless to say, the poll worker was not amused. I guess in Maryland you have to check your sense of humor at the door when you enter the polls.”

The 5: Growing up in the Chicago area, your editor was well acquainted with the expression “Vote early and often” from a young age.

There’s an entire Wikipedia page devoted to the phrase and its variants, although its research might be suspect. Regardless, the phrase has been attributed at times to three Chicagoans — gangster Al Capone and mayors “Big Bill” Thompson (1915–1923 and 1927–1931) and Richard J. Daley (1955-1976).

Depending on whom you want to believe, the notoriously corrupt Thompson said it first and the others took their cue from him…

Have a good weekend,

David Gonigam

Dave Gonigam
The 5 Min. Forecast

P.S. We’re now only five days away from the Weekly Cash Flow Summit, featuring Agora Financial’s newest superstar contributor — Rich Dad, Poor Dad author Robert Kiyosaki.

Next Wednesday, Nov. 14, at 1:00 p.m. EST, Robert will reveal a revolutionary technique for pulling in weekly streams of cash — up to five figures, depending on how you execute the strategy.

Sign up at this link with your email address and we’ll shoot you a reminder complete with a link to the event as we get closer to the day.

Dave Gonigam

Dave Gonigam

Dave Gonigam has been managing editor of The 5 Min. Forecast since September 2010. Before joining the research and writing team at Agora Financial in 2007, he worked for 20 years as an Emmy award-winning television news producer.

Recent Alerts

New Ticket out of the Rat Race

Nearly two years into the pandemic, 4 million Americans who had jobs in February 2020 still don’t have jobs now. Did they all become crypto millionaires and drop out? Read More

Climate Mandates

The most alarming article in a long time… also gives hope. Read More

Tesla Is Toast, Unless…

Expect mass EV adoption, says Ray Blanco, “by making batteries smaller, more powerful and, most importantly, more affordable.” Read More

All In (Crypto)

Here’s a novel spin on one of the biggest financial stories of the week so far… Read More


Will fresh lockdowns — resulting from a new COVID-19 variant — put inflation back in its box? Read More

Crypto Riches: Still Not Too Late

“My sense is more investors would… own crypto assets if they felt it were as simple and transparent as owning stocks,” says crypto investor James Altucher. Read More

Exodus From China

Now it might be easier than ever to get your hands on a crypto miner… Read More

Crypto Terrorists!

A traditional finance titan is threatened by the “stick-it-to-the man” appeal of crypto — an ethos that goes all the way back to a white paper describing Bitcoin in 2008. Read More

Moon Over the Market

You might have had the chance to savor the sight of the lunar eclipse… But did you also ponder the possibility of a severe market crash? Read More

Underground Way to Play EVs

“Chargers manufactured, owned and operated by a handful of new charging infrastructure companies,” says Ray Blanco, “will soon dot the highways.” Read More