Smart Beta and Steamrollers

  • Wall Street strategist frets his own creation might blow up
  • The wizards of Jane Street… 1998 hubris revisited?
  • The reality of ETFs: “If just one thing goes wrong, you get killed”
  • ISIS gives up on gold dinar… but profits from Iraqi dinar!
  • The safety trade is on… Interpol and iPhone encryption… gold versus white yak dung… and more!

Whaddya know? The hottest strategy in exchange-traded funds could go “horribly wrong” — says the man who developed the strategy.
Only yesterday we mentioned that “smart beta” ETFs are how all the cool kids invest now. These ETFs essentially invest in an index… but make adjustments to outperform the index by, say, excluding stocks that had been super-volatile in the past couple of years.
Morningstar says assets under management in smart beta strategies have grown sixfold since 2008, to $616 billion — growth that parallels the explosion of ETFs.
The pioneer in smart beta is Rob Arnott, CEO of a firm called Research Affiliates.
Mr. Arnott now says smart beta has become so popular that its performance is bound to tank sooner or later.
“I thought the growth in smart beta was a good thing,” he’s quoted in today’s Financial Times. “Now when I see product proliferation in areas that I think are unwise and that are putting people at risk of performance chasing, that growth ceases to be a good thing.”
In other words, the strategy works only if a few people do it. If everyone tries to do it, it’ll backfire. A report from Arnott’s firm says the reason many smart beta strategies are outperforming these days is not the brilliance of the strategy… but simply that the underlying stocks have become more expensive.
“If you buy what has gone up just because it has gone up,” Arnott sums up, “you are buying for reasons that have nothing to do with valuations and run the risk of buying at the top of a bubble.”
At least Mr. Arnott has the decency to give retail investors a heads-up.
Don’t expect any such warning from the folks at Jane Street — described in today’s New York Times as “a secretive ETF trading firm that, after years of minting money in the shadows of Wall Street, is now pitching itself to some of the largest institutional investors in the world.”
Jane Street has also grown like a weed along with ETFs in recent years — its net worth multiplying fourfold since 2007, to more than $1 billion.
Its trading methods are so exotic that it hires “only a handful of new employees each year,” says the Times. “To survive, candidates have to ace brain-twisting math riddles and game theory tests.” Then they go through a one-month boot camp in which they master the firm’s proprietary computer program — if they don’t already know how to write code themselves.
It was Jane Street’s market makers who swooped in the morning of Aug. 24, 2015 — when the Dow plunged 1,100 points in five minutes and many ETFs experienced price drops completely out of line with their underlying indexes.
We mentioned one example yesterday — the Vanguard Consumer Staples ETF (VDC) cliff-diving 32% that morning while its underlying index fell only 9%. The move isn’t hard to spot on this one-year chart…

Jane Street’s math whizzes and computer programs spotted these mismatches. They bought with both hands and profited handsomely.
This is what Jane Street tries to pull off with ETFs every day. Most of the time, the mismatches aren’t so obvious. But they’re there. And the profits can be captured in the space of nanoseconds. Other market-making firms are catching on to these techniques — Cantor Fitzgerald, Knight Capital.
“As these firms have grown,” the Gray Lady goes on, “so has the demand for a new breed of Wall Street trader — one who can build financial models and write computer code but who also has the guts to spot a market anomaly and bet big with the firm’s capital.”
Reading the Times story, your editor couldn’t help thinking about 1998… and the hedge fund Long Term Capital Management.
You might be familiar with the story: LTCM was run by Nobel Prize winners with flawless mathematical models. Unfortunately, they’d back-tested their models only 15 years and failed to account for the possibility the Russian government might default on its debt. When Russia defaulted, LTCM went down and nearly took the global financial system with it.
Is Jane Street subject to the same hubris?
Consider how nearly all of Wall Street is trying to do what Jane Street pioneered with the ETF trade. The Times story quotes a 31-year-old trading whiz hired in the New York office of the Japanese bank Mizuho. “There are so many moving parts; if just one thing goes wrong, you get killed.”
In other words, Wall Street now devotes thousands of Ph.D.s and terabytes of computer power to the market equivalent of picking up pennies in front of a steamroller.
How long can that go on before someone gets run over and we’re looking at another 1998 — only worse? That’s, in essence, the question David Stockman has been raising in this space for several days now.
ETFs have had a great run since the stock market rally began in 2009. “Every time an ETF started trading above the net asset value of the underlying stocks due to speculator buying,” David says, “fund providers issued new ETF shares to market makers. These market makers, in turn, bought up a basket of shares on the stock exchanges representing the asset mix of the fund. They then swapped them for the ETF shares.”
Now that the market has topped, what happens when that process starts to go into reverse?
What happens when Jane Street and its cohorts don’t swoop in to buy those underpriced ETF shares? What happens when a “doomsday loop” kicks in… when the market makers for ETFs are forced to dump the underlying stocks… dragging down the indexes… forcing still more selling?
The Financial Times and the New York Times seem to understand bits and pieces of this unfolding disaster. But they haven’t been able to put it all together. David Stockman, meanwhile, has been holed up for weeks at his place in Aspen, Colorado, figuring out how you can avoid getting steamrolled — indeed, how you can parlay the coming ETF meltdown into gains of up to 300% by this July.
In a little over 24 hours from now… live from Aspen… David will lead an online workshop where he’ll reveal the fruits of his research. It’s tomorrow at 7:00 p.m. EST. If you’re tied up tomorrow night, we’ll have a replay available to watch later.
It won’t cost you a thing to watch this live event. All we ask is that you send us your email address so we know how many people to expect and our computer servers don’t crash. Sign-up takes you only seconds — click here to secure your spot.
As oil goes, so goes the stock market… and today the direction is down.
After a 7% run-up yesterday, West Texas Intermediate crude is down nearly 5% as we write — back to $31.76.
In sympathy, all the major U.S. indexes are down about 1% — the Dow shedding more than 150 points, the S&P knocked back to 1,926.
Hot money is seeking shelter in Treasuries and gold. The yield on a 10-year T-note is back to 1.74%. Gold is up $16, to $1,224.
So much for ISIS’ dreams of a new gold dinar.
It was in November 2014 The 5 first took note of plans by the world’s most notorious jihadis to make gold and silver the coin of their growing realm in eastern Syria and western Iraq. By August of last year, one of ISIS’ characteristically slick videos was denouncing the “financial system of enslavement, underpinned by a piece of paper called the Federal Reserve dollar note.”
That was then, this is now: The Associated Press cites sources within ISIS-controlled territory as saying “the extremist group started accepting only dollars for ‘tax’ payments, water and electric bills.” As in U.S. dollars.
The White House is quick to claim credit. Of late, the U.S. military has been bombing sites where ISIS is believed to be stashing cash. “We are seeing our efforts having some effect on their financial flows,” says the president’s counterterrorism adviser, Lisa Monaco.
Then again, ISIS is nothing if not resourceful: “Islamic State militants in the northern Iraqi city of Mosul,” says Reuters, “are manipulating the exchange rate between U.S. dollars and Iraqi dinars to squeeze money out of local people as coalition bombers attack the group’s finances.
“The group earns dollars by selling basic commodities produced in factories under its control to local distributors, but pays monthly salaries in dinars to thousands of fighters and public employees.”
By capturing the spread, ISIS pockets gains of 20%, the newswire says.
Ha! After more than a decade of shady characters promising big profits to Americans from the Iraqi dinar, it took ISIS to figure out how to do it for real. O the irony…
“Try watching the National Geographic Channel show Underworld Inc. — Season 2, Episode 7, titled ‘The Black Market,’” advises a reader on the subject of iPhone encryption.
“It seems that an iPhone stolen in the U.S. makes it to South America, where they are cracked and refurbished to appear legitimate. If they are caught in a police raid before they make it onto the street, Interpol can still extract the original information from them. (In the show, they show an extracted picture of a male wrapped in the American flag.)
“So tell me again why the underworld and Interpol can do this and the U.S. feds need extra help compromising these devices? Maybe they should send a rep to the Interpol South American office to find out how it is really done, thereby leaving Apple and Google to concentrate on making these devices theftproof.
“With an original air date of Oct. 20, 2015, problem documented and solved four months ago. Now tell me what the Feds really want?
“Love The 5, been a loyal reader since inception. Thanks, and please keep up the good work.”
The 5: Hmmm… How old were the phones? It’s the newer models that have the end-to-end encryption.
Oh… about the FBI’s pious claim that its fight with Apple is only over the San Bernardino shooting…

That didn’t last long…
“What about the shorting ETFs,” a reader inquires after David Stockman’s ETF warning — like UDN and SH?
The 5: Well, no one holds inverse ETFs for a long stretch of time — or they shouldn’t, anyway. The bigger concern is the long ETFs that retail investors buy and hold. Even Wall Street pros trade in and out of them, and their underlying stocks, at lightning speed. (See above.)
“News flash for Jim the gold bug,” writes a reader who clearly agrees with the “You can’t eat gold” line of thinking.
“In business school 45 years ago, I had a professor who advocated replacing gold with white yak dung. It is rarer, easier to mine and more valuable. He never said if the dung or the yak was white.
“I have read how great gold is all the way down from $1,800 an ounce. It’s a trade I have never believed in, and will gladly miss this opportunity.
“I like things you do not have to assay, insure and store. Like good-quality stocks and bonds.”
“I enjoy scanning The 5 for comments like this from the herd,” writes one of our longtimers by way of reply.
“Maybe we are getting close to a bottom in gold if the herd is back to despising it with bumper-sticker rationales like this.
“The morphic fields of the herd appear to be shifting like a flock of starlings at dusk.”
“Sigh — not this s*** again,” affirms another reader more emphatically.
“Look, gold (and silver, etc.) are simply media of exchange. They are not food and are simply possible methods of procuring such. I do not attempt to eat a medium of exchange any more than I would try to consume my rifle or automobile for sustenance.
“The whole blather about ‘You can’t eat gold’ ranks among the most insipid arguments I have ever heard, and people spouting it ought to be prohibited from speaking in public, breeding or voting.”
The 5: How about from owning firearms? Heh…
Best regards,
Dave Gonigam
The 5 Min. Forecast
P.S. Did you know 31,729 Americans learned how to piggyback “Canadian social security” last year?
Instead of solely relying on the U.S. government’s Ponzi retirement plan, thousands of folks are taking their retirement into their own hands — making real money!
Today — without giving up a single penny of your U.S. Social Security — you can join them and learn how to collect real-life dividend checks that could supplement your retirement almost immediately.
But hurry, click here — you never know when this “loophole” could close.

Dave Gonigam

Dave Gonigam

Dave Gonigam has been managing editor of The 5 Min. Forecast since September 2010. Before joining the research and writing team at Agora Financial in 2007, he worked for 20 years as an Emmy award-winning television news producer.

Recent Alerts

Apple’s “Quadruple Whammy”

Our main topic today surrounds the world’s biggest company — or what was once the world’s biggest until it was recently eclipsed. Read More

Bear Markets Don’t Matter (When You’re Starving)

We interrupt this impending bear market for another timely warning about famine. Read More

Avoid This Bear-Market Blunder

“Could you share some suggestions for people who are stuck with margin loans?” a reader asks our income-and-retirement expert Zach Scheidt. Read More

Ruble Rebound (Oops)

Let’s see… How is Washington’s campaign of economic warfare against Moscow going? Read More

The “Strong Dollar” Myth

You can’t escape headlines in the Establishment media about the strong U.S. dollar. But… strong compared with what? Read More

Finger-Pointing Time (Crypto)

Our resident crypto evangelist James Altucher tackles whether last week really amounted to crypto’s “Lehman moment” akin to the 2008 financial crisis. Read More

Here Come Gas Lines

Can you say price controls? House Dems will introduce supposed anti-price gouging legislation next week. Which doesn’t bode well for inflation… Read More

Crypto Chaos

Coinbase (COIN) is not going bankrupt. It just looks that way seeing as its share price has been slashed by… Read More

Wrong Opinions = Financial Lockout

The most important developments on the free-speech front in recent days do not involve Elon Musk and Donald Trump. Read More

Famine & Freezers

After a cheery edition of The 5 contemplating nuclear war yesterday, we turn our attention today to… famine. Read More